Having had a crack at describing categories of record collectors (called Vinyl Hunter-Gatherers around these parts), this post continues looking at further case studies, your correspondent once again being the mandated patient. Sorry, that should read ‘volunteer’.

Enthusiast (B): ‘Excellent — a very satisfying find. Wonder if I can swing a discount’.

Chicago live in Japan

Chicago — Live in Japan [CBS 1972]

This double live album had been on my ‘want’ list for years.

After the monster that was Chicago IV —a four LP live album recorded at New York’s Carnegie hall— you’d think that enough was more than enough. But that quadruple album has a thin sound and performances that run hot and cold; it just wasn’t the grab-you-by-the-scruff-of-the-neck ‘in concert’ document that you’d hope for from a band whose surge of brass-driven rock-jazz creativity started in 1969 and, at this stage, showed little sign of tapering off. (It did, quite soon afterwards, but that’s another story). So when I heard about this Japan-only release, recorded the year after IV while the band was in the land of the rising sun, I was more than curious. Rare and good and live. That’s a combination to hit the Vinyl Connection sweet spot every time.

But I only ever saw it once, and it was prohibitively expensive so I passed. And guess what? I regretted not digging deeper into my pouch of Yen. Passed over now and regretted later — every record collector knows the story.

And so, a couple of Sunday’s ago while on a visit to an eastern suburbs den of vinylity, I saw it again. Yep, it was still expensive. Boo hiss, it had a significant scratch at the beginning of side four. The cover was excellent, clean and straight, though the OBI (those paper strips on Japanese pressings that collectors get so excited about) was missing. My response was not quite, ‘Big fucking deal, I’m buying it so there’, it was more furrowed brow and fretful wavering, but the result is what counts. And as everyone knows, you gotta listen through the surface noise, man.

Actually, after a good clean, the scratch isn’t too noticeable and the recording is terrific.

With each side of this double album clocking in between 24 and 26 minutes, there’s a lot of music. Side one is particularly strong, with the edgy punch and spirited blowing on ‘A hit by Varese’ being a highlight. That all but one song on this side are from the album Chicago V, still a month from release at the time of recording, says much about the band’s confidence in the material.

Chicago Live Japan insert

The second side is dominated by James Pankow’s ‘Ballet for a girl in Buchannon’ (Chicago II), a suite I enjoy for it’s varied patchwork of pieces. This is where the hit ‘Colour my world’ comes from, a pretty ballad that unfortunately indicated where the band would position itself by the mid-70s.

A couple of unreleased songs spice things up for attentive fans (Terry Kath’s ‘Mississippi delta city blues’ was a live favourite that later reappeared on Chicago XI; ‘A song for Richard and his friends’ appeared on IV) while devotees of the debut album (your correspondent amongst them) are well catered for with four songs, including Chicago’s boisterous encore version of the Spencer Davis hit, ‘I’m a man’. Chicago III, often ignored when the band’s early recordings are considered, contributes two songs (‘Lowdown’ and ‘Free’) and there is a barnstorming version of ‘25 or 6 to 4’ from the second album. It’s exciting ensemble playing full of energy and momentum, just what a live album should be. If you think of schmaltzy ballads when Chicago is mentioned, check out albums I, II and V, and grab this ripper rarity if you see it.

In sum, an excellent Category B acquisition, despite the scratch not resulting in a discount.


Desperado (G): ‘Not very interesting, possibly not very good, but I simply must take home something. Preferably several somethings’.

Wetton Manzanera

Wetton – Manzanera — Wetton Manzanera [Geffen 1987]

I like Phil Manzanera a lot. He’s appeared at VC before, and just recently I enthusiastically purchased an upgrade copy of the excellent Primitive Guitars. During a recent lunchtime record store trawl, I found myself clutching Wetton-Manzanera despite several clear indicators that I shouldn’t.

One: Phil’s 80s jacket on the front cover. Yuk. Poor taste in clothes = poor music, doesn’t it? At least, that’s the sense I make of that entire decade of pop music.

Two: John Wetton was much closer to the tragedy of Asia than his sterling work with King Crimson.

Three: The titles suggest a slew of mainstream boy-girl songs. Put this together with JW’s bleached blonde LA rock star look and it spells trouble.

On the plus side, Alan White is on drums and Kevin Godly on backing vocals.

Three votes against and one half-hearted vote in favour. I bought it of course.

You will not be surprised to hear that the album lived down to expectations. Pedestrian AOR with that brittle, two-dimensional production typical of aspiring radio-friendly rock in the second half of the 80s. To be honest I cannot find a highlight. Sadly, this one fits Category G perfectly.


Scrooge (H): ‘It’s cheap. Better buy it (even though I’ll only listen once then file for eternity)’.

Tony  Banks – Bankstatement [Virgin 1989]


Of course I grabbed this for fifty pence when it turned up in a Charity Shop dig in the UK not long back. I mean, it’s a solo album by Genesis keyboard maestro Tony Banks, isn’t it? With a clever title, too. Can’t be all bad, surely? Just look at the back cover photo.

Bankstatement - back

Allmusic puts Bankstatement in three categories: Album rock, Contemporary Pop/Rock, Prog-rock (note hyphen). I’d proportion the musical content thusly: 20%, 75%, 5%. As a serious prog-head (note hyphen), this was a cheap but  unsatisfying purchase. I could, of course, listen a few more time and extract some highlights for you, but I’m not going to. 50p was too much. It is likely my time would have been better spent snoozing, as this purchase proved the record-collector adage, ‘You Scrooge, You Lose’. Another Category H record ready for filing.


If you have a category story to share, please do. It’ll help me feel more normal.


  1. So this must explain why I always had a copy of Bankstatement used, in stock, at all times.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I suspect so, Mike. It’s an intercontinental stinker.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Apparently so! However I also had perennial copies of The Way We Walk live albums in stock at all times…I think that may have been more the fault of record clubs and whatnot.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. This post was much closer to your sterling last categorizing post than any Asia musical tragedy!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Phew! You’re only as good as your last album… er, post.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Poor Tony. He so wanted his own “Mike and the Mechanics” success too. Well, at least we have “A Curious Feeling.”

    Liked by 1 person

    1. And of course both Mike and Tony yearned for just a fraction of Phil’s success. Ah, family tensions. They’ve been around since the book of Genesis.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. It seems the Op shops I occasionally visit around where I work stock only Scroogedly cast-offs. (I should know as I have made such donations).


    1. Too true, I’m afraid. Visited 3 Op Shops this morning and saw nothing. Not even a battered Phill Collins LP.


  5. I like Tony Banks, but I’m afraid that back cover would’ve been a deal breaker for me, even at 50p

    Liked by 2 people

    1. So you can judge a book (or LP) by its cover, eh?


  6. Chicago I, II, and V — masterpieces all, and the only three Chicagos I have at present. I owned Chicago X – the chocolate bar one – as a kid and remember liking it, but haven’t yet recovered it. I don’t think I’ve ever heard any Chicago live and am now intrigued. No Japan excursions on the horizon but idea being filed regardless.

    The Wetton/Manzanera and Bank warnings are much appreciated. Even when playing the Scrooge or Desperado roles, I still find myself holding out unrealistic hopes for a beautiful surprise when conducting that first post-purchase spin; I can’t seem to protect against exaggerated expectations so the disappointment always hits even when only pocket change has been spent.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. X was my first Chicago album – based on the saccharine single ‘If you leave me now’ I’m embarrassed to say – and it wasn’t until much later that I discovered the early stuff. With you on I, II, and V. After that, meh. I find III worthwhile and this live one (which I believe is out on CD) is great.

      Re Scrooge/Desperado, there ARE sometimes unexpected delights, which is probably what keeps us digging and carting home dreck*. Hope spins eternal; disappointment returns, unavoidable.

      * a fine word I read in a blog somewhere recently 😉


  7. Bank Statement – has an LP ever had such a good front and such a bad back cover?

    I fall into the Enthusiast category here, having painfully weaned myself away from being a Desperado – never picked anything worthwhile up that way, as I realised after years and years and years of doing it!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You are truly an evolved being, Joe, if your Desperado has come to his senses.

      Liked by 1 person

  8. Definitely more of the enthusiast, Bruce. One of my most satisfying finds was Sinatra At The Sands a few months ago. Little scuffed, but for £3 I wasn’t turning it down (plays fine). That said, I have gone for the odd Scrooge purchase once or twice (Billy Joel’s Innocent Man set me back 50p – though it’s been played only once, I actually fairly enjoyed it).

    Liked by 1 person

Comments and responses welcome for all posts: present or past. Please join in!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: